Maybe We Should Care About The Game Awards More, Actually
It’s been 12 years since the inception of The Game Awards under Geoff Keighley, and every year brings familiar posts and pieces about how the show fails to meet its stated purpose of recognizing and upholding the creative and technical excellence in video games. The most common criticism is that the nominations and winners are not reflective of the best games of the year. Still, as the most prominent gaming awards show out there, developers and media members alike are tuned into those announcements.
Given that the voting body is made up of only the most prominent games media outlets — which themselves have narrowed their staff and the scope of their critical work — it isn’t shocking that games made with the intent of broad appeal are broadly more appealing to a more general and homogeneous voting bloc.

In fact, Janet Garcia of MinnMax made a few threads on Bluesky [1][2] about the subject that point to this as an expected outcome of the voting process. Certainly, there are arguments to be made here about how this process facilitates the perception that large sales equate to artistic merit, but the issues ultimately run much deeper than this.
If all it took to arrive at such selections were large voting bodies, we would expect to see similar things happen in awards shows for other mediums, but this is much less likely to hold in those spaces — Spider-Man: Brand New Day is unlikely to sweep the Oscars, for instance. Looking at the structure of the show itself gives us some clues as to why that may be.
Writer and critic Joshua Rivera wrote a great piece [3] on The Game Awards last year that goes into great detail about what The Game Awards is doing — who it is for, how it differs from other awards shows, and its deleterious effects on the gaming space as a whole.
“This is not a show made for humans. It thinks very little of the people who make games, and it thinks even less of the people that play them. And I think every little thing done to give them credence — every podcast discussion or article about its trailers and winners and column chronicling that awards horse race — has worked to cement the place where it all sits.”
— Joshua Rivera from his piece "but the games were good"
The piece is full of salient points, all of which remain relevant this year. At the end of that piece, Rivera calls for readers to consider how harmful The Game Awards have been, and if we as readers and writers should truly be willing to align ourselves with the medium outlook that the awards show seems to be pushing.
While Rivera does not explicitly call for people to boycott or avoid The Game Awards, there is a strong implication that the show and its current format are ultimately beneath us. It is a big-picture look at the ills of the industry and surrounding conversations that I agree with, but I wonder if a different approach to the problems at hand is worth consideration in spite of these truths.
Rather than adhering to complete divestment from the media apparatus and economic structures that make The Game Awards possible, let us envision a world where we care about The Game Awards much more than people already do, one where it is important to us — the remaining games media and the showrunners — that the ceremony actually meets its stated purpose. What would that look like? What would be required of media members (the actual voting body behind the results Geoff Keighley gets chastised for) to see this to fruition?
It’s easy to point at the figurehead behind the awards and shift the blame there. In some respects, he’s asked for it by openly making himself a sin-eater for the corporate side of the industry, and it’s a job he seems to both love and take very seriously. But if the process is to be believed, he’s not the guy who chose to write in 007: First Light for the “Best Narrative” award, is he?
These are some of the best-reviewed games this year, not just the most financially successful. While it is true that the nominees themselves are a narrow view of the medium, these selections are representative of how the critical space currently operates.
The sad reality is that, broadly speaking, games media is not in a healthy place. The obvious symptoms include venture-capital buyouts of outlets, massive layoffs, and a shift to clickbait-style titles and SEO-focused writing, but less often considered is the degradation of the art of criticism itself.
Pick up almost any review about a single game from a major outlet from the last few years, and you’ll notice that the contents of these reviews are eerily similar in style and subject matter: a list of features, developer credits, a verdict on whether the writer enjoyed it, and maybe a surface-level pass at themes. Little can be found in these pieces that couldn’t be gleaned from a game’s trailer or other marketing material, with explanation being held up as the ultimate aim of critique.
There are, undoubtedly, corporate pressures that result in the aforementioned homogeneity. The layoffs have disproportionately affected POC and women in the media space, and have pushed out more experienced and unconventional voices, leaving vacuums for skeleton crews and limited perspectives to fill. Editorial direction can also shape what types of writing are allowed to exist, whether that is for traffic generation or safety. Dan Stapleton, IGN’s former Director of Reviews, has openly stated [4] that sites will often go with the same, narrow freelance cohort because they are a known quantity.

The factors we can point to are innumerable, and it’s not as if all the work is wholly without merit, so the status quo is upheld. But if top-level pressures were the extent of the issue, why is it that each layoff is followed by a new “independent” outlet being spun up, only to take this exact approach to games criticism?
I’ve heard the podcasts, man. It’s not your boss that limits your perspective.
The ills of the writing space are not wholly downstream of the corporate decisions of gaming outlets. Because these tech-review-styled critical pieces have become the norm, they reinforce the exact same habits in new talent, which bleed into coverage surrounding the awards themselves — it is a recursive sickness.
I’ve heard the podcasts, man. It’s not your boss that limits your perspective.
This can be hard to hear, but this shallow approach to games criticism fits right in with The Game Awards’ approach to showcasing video games as an art form. If the media members behind the nominations and winner selections cannot be bothered to dig deeper into what the games they play are doing, what right do they have to ask for more from the show itself? Even if we managed to mold The Game Awards into a show more aligned with its ideals in presentation, the representative games selected would continue to be narrow because the predominant approach to criticism remains the same.
And so, in order to make The Game Awards (or any media-driven awards show, really) better representative of the art it is advocating for, some level of seriousness must be applied to the art of criticism at scale. Critics must be more rigorous and exacting in the ways they speak about and evaluate games. Can you tell the reader something about your experience with the game that they can’t get from a Nintendo Direct? Can you point to the elements of a game and explain how they shaped your experience with the work? Can you bring a unique, individual perspective to your writing and apply that to building an argument beyond “buy this game”?
Furthermore, voters need to be more intimately informed about the subjects they are voting on. Smaller panels of critics for each genre are a great place to start. It is much easier to ensure a small panel of people is both capable and willing to interrogate a game’s narrative in an effort to determine which games have the “best narrative” versus expecting an assortment of 100 different outlets to arrive at a coherent answer. And if a critic’s strength is not in that area, they can apply themselves elsewhere; I can hear music and point to its effect on me in a moment, but there are many people in games media better-equipped to speak about the craft at the highest level.
"It is much easier to ensure a small panel of people is both capable and willing to interrogate a game’s narrative in an effort to determine which games have the “best narrative” versus expecting an assortment of 100 different outlets to arrive at a coherent answer."
Equally important is the breadth of games played as an individual. If someone is to be on a panel for “Best Action Game”, then they must play a large number of different games in that category — including indie and AA titles, not just the big-name releases. It is not necessarily about being a genre “expert” or having decades of familiarity; it is more about having the ability and desire to apply a critical framework to these things that does not exist at scale in the current landscape.
Diligence of this magnitude may seem unreasonable given the number of games released each year and the scope of each title when placed against every person’s limited free time for playing games, but this is alleviated by dedicating smaller panels to specific genres and categories so that an individual’s purview stays focused rather than spanning every award.
Such a voting body would need to be determined earlier in the year, with members in contact with each other to help guide toward, recommend, and discuss games they find noteworthy in each category. It doesn't have to be something substantial; a text thread would surely suffice. There are technically no "right" answers for a process like this, but what games panelists choose to put forward and why says something about them, communicating to the audience and other critics alike what we can (and should) value in a video game.
Doing this wouldn’t fix every flaw in such a corporate-focused awards show — big-budget spectacle and commercial incentives are only alleviated if the showrunners decide to take that direction — but it’s a practical step critics could take that makes their criticism more meaningful beyond the launch-week hype cycle, regardless of what happens on stage. A more fully representative awards show then becomes a byproduct of a healthier critical field.
Of course, the easiest way to avoid the “embarrassment” of The Game Awards is to stop treating it as important. Maybe it will just cease to be a big deal to other people if the media members turn away from it, but that doesn’t really change anything beyond Keighley’s feelings, and widespread displeasure with the show speaks to something larger going on that the show's elimination cannot resolve on its own.
Truthfully, The Game Awards are not a load-bearing pillar of video games as a medium. The teams making the work and the players engaging with it are. Nominees will never match every individual’s taste, but if critics bring real rigor and care to the conversation, we can push much better, more varied work into view.
The stage is already set, so why not take it?
Reference:
.png)




Comments